Northern Technologies International Corporation

Northern Technologies International Corporation

$13.86
-0.15 (-1.07%)
NASDAQ Global Market
USD, US
Chemicals - Specialty

Northern Technologies International Corporation (NTIC) Q3 2016 Earnings Call Transcript

Published at 2016-07-07 17:00:00
Operator
Good day, ladies and gentlemen, and welcome to the Northern Technologies International Corporation Third Quarter 2016 Earnings Conference Call and Webcast. At this time, all participants are in a listen-only mode. Later, we will conduct a question-and-answer session and instructions will follow at that time. [Operator Instructions]. As a reminder, this conference call is being recorded. As part of the discussion today, the representatives from NTIC will be making certain forward-looking statements regarding NTIC's future financial and operating results, as well as their business plans, objectives and expectations. Please be advised that these forward-looking statements are covered under the Safe Harbor provisions of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995 and that NTIC desires to avail itself from the protections of the Safe Harbor for these statements. Please also be advised that actual results could differ materially from those stated or implied by the forward-looking statements due to certain risks and uncertainties, including those described in NTIC's most recent annual report on Form 10-K, subsequent quarterly reports on Form 10-Q and recent press releases. Please read these reports and other future filings that NTIC will make with the SEC. NTIC disclaims any duty to update or revise its forward-looking statements. I would now like to turn the conference over to Mr. Patrick Lynch, President and CEO. Please go ahead.
Patrick Lynch
Good morning. I am Patrick Lynch, NTIC's CEO and I’m here with Matt Wolsfeld, NTIC's CFO. Please note that our financial results for the third quarter of fiscal 2016 were included in a press release issued earlier this morning, a copy of which is available at ntic.com. During this call, we will review various key aspects of our fiscal 2016 third quarter financial results, give a brief business update, comment on our net sales and earnings guidance for the full fiscal year, and then conclude with a question-and-answer session. We experienced net sales growth of 4.9% for the fiscal 2016 third quarter, driven primarily by a 25% growth in worldwide Natur-Tec sales of over $1.5 million. While overall, ZERUST industrial sales increased almost 3% due to stronger sales at NTIC China, North American industrial ZERUST sales dipped slightly due to soft demand from the slowing agricultural and heavy equipment sectors. Also, despite the numerous challenges facing the oil and gas industry over the past 12 months, sales of NTIC’s oil and gas group increased slightly in the third quarter to just over $500,000. The total sales by our joint ventures, which we do not consolidate on our income statement were up 24.8% to $24.2 million for the fiscal 2016 third quarter compared to $19.4 million for the fiscal 2016 second quarter. Year-to-date, however, JV sales have declined 12.8% to $66.2 million, which is indicative of the challenges faced during the first half of the fiscal year including the absence of our former Chinese joint venture sales, the significant weakening of major foreign currencies in comparison to the U.S. dollar, and weaker demand for our ZERUST products in Europe. We are optimistic that the increase in JV sales during the third quarter demonstrates that demand is building across our JV network. However, we continue to closely monitor all of our markets and we are proactively working with our JV partners to strengthen market share and improve performance globally. Sales at our wholly-owned NTIC China subsidiary have continued to improve in each quarter since starting operations in January 2015, and having just enjoyed our first quarter with over $1 million in sales, we are encouraged about our long-term potential in China. Our management team in China is very strong and is helping us navigate in an exceptionally competitive and complex market. While not currently breakeven on a quarterly basis, we believe that as sales continue to ramp we will end the year with a monthly sales run rate at a breakeven level and expect our Chinese operations will contribute to profits next fiscal year. NTIC China sales and corresponding gross profits have helped offset some operating expenses related to our Chinese operations. Nevertheless, year-to-date, we have still been forced to absorb a $1.4 million impact related to the termination of our JV license agreement with Tianjin Zerust and the formation and operation of NTIC China. As we outlined in our press release this morning, since the termination of the agreement in January 2015, our former Chinese JV has yet to release financial statements to NTIC and agree to an orderly liquidation. As a result, we are currently evaluating if and when we need to write down our $1.9 million investment in this former joint venture. If the company were to decide to write down this investment, the company would incur a $1.1 million non-cash charge for all our 60% proportional ownership of this JV entity. We continue to litigate against our former Chinese partner in both the United States and China, and this is expected to continue into our fiscal 2017. We continue to expect a favorable outcome in the coming quarters regarding this lawsuit. Finally, as it relates to our transformation in China, it is important to note that during the first nine months of fiscal 2016, NTIC did not record any royalty or equity income from Tianjin Zerust. During the first nine months of fiscal 2015, prior to the termination of the license agreement, Tianjin Zerust contributed over $376,000 of royalties and equity income to NTIC compared to no royalties and no equity income to NTIC during the first nine months of fiscal 2016. The pre-tax impact on NTIC’s earnings for the first nine months of fiscal 2016 of both the direct expenses associated to China and the absence of the royalty and equity income amounted to $1.8 million or $0.39 per share. This obviously caused a significant impact to NTIC's earnings during fiscal 2016. All said, NTIC reported net income of $0.20 per diluted share for the third quarter and $0.13 per diluted share for the nine months of fiscal 2016 compared to net income attributable to NTIC of $0.20 per diluted share during the third quarter and $0.39 per diluted share for the nine months of fiscal 2015. Now regarding our oil and gas business. During the third quarter of 2016, our North American oil and gas team continued to focus its sales efforts primarily on protecting the bottom plates of oil storage tanks in North America from corrosion. As we stated in previous quarterly calls, customers in this industry segment have been revising their infrastructure expansion and maintenance budgets to address the dramatic fluctuations in global oil prices we've seen over the past 12 months. As a result, our oil and gas net sales were up slightly in the fiscal 2016 third quarter but were down 11.1% for the nine months of fiscal 2016 compared to the same period last fiscal year. Despite the challenging industry backdrop, however, our oil and gas team has continued to achieve significant milestones which include signing a distribution and installation partnership agreement in the United States with a large service provider and receiving an order from a global oil company for installation in a new country. Furthermore, since our oil and gas sales exceeded $300,000 in June, we remain optimistic that our oil and gas net sales for fiscal 2016 will finish stronger. Nevertheless, we continue to anticipate that our financial results from sales of ZERUST corrosion inhibiting products into the oil and gas industry will continue to be choppy with spikes in sales as opportunities are converted and revenue is recognized over the next few years. Now turning to our Natur-Tec bioplastics business. For the fiscal 2016 third quarter, Natur-Tec sales were a record $1.5 million, a 25% increase over the same period last year. This increase was due to higher sales of finished products to NTIC's majority-owned subsidiary in India as well as increased sales in North America through our domestic distribution network. We continue to see a strong demand for finished products such as compostable bags and cutlery in North America as a direct result of increases in zero-waste initiatives as well as favorable local and state-level waste management regulations. We also anticipate further adoption of our product lines by key customers in India and also several new customers coming online in North America during the remainder of fiscal 2016 and beyond, as we continue to target and convert additional customers globally to use our sustainable solutions. Overall, I am pleased with our third quarter financial performance. I'm also encouraged with the direction NTIC is headed, the business plan we have created, and the many growth opportunities we have in front of us. While fiscal 2016 has been a volatile year with many moving parts, I am confident we are making significant progress toward enhancing our global brands and believe we are well positioned for significant long-term profitable growth. At this point, let me turn the call over to Matt Wolsfeld to summarize our financial results for the third quarter of fiscal 2016.
Matt Wolsfeld
Thanks, Patrick. Net sales of NTIC's ZERUST products increased 1.5% across our industrial market and oil and gas market segment during the third quarter of fiscal 2016 compared to the same period in fiscal '15. ZERUST oil and gas net sales were $512,000 during the third quarter of fiscal 2016, up 1.6% compared to $504,000 in the three months ended May 31, 2015. Net sales of ZERUST corrosion inhibiting products for our joint ventures decreased over 9% during the third quarter of fiscal 2016 compared to the same quarter in 2015. Income provided by our joint venture operations decreased by 0.4% to $3 million in the third quarter of fiscal 2016 compared to the prior fiscal year quarter. This small decline was a significant improvement over the $2.5 million and $1.9 million earned in the first and second quarters of fiscal 2016, respectively. We’re hopeful that this increase in joint venture income demonstrates that demand is stabilizing and increasing across our joint venture network. Lastly, net sales of our Natur-Tec products increased 25% to $1.5 million during the third quarter of fiscal 2016 compared to the same quarter of fiscal 2015. Our total operating expenses were $4.7 million in fiscal 2016 third quarter which was a 3.6% increase compared to the third quarter of fiscal 2015. This increase was primarily a result of the expenses related to the formation and establishment of NTIC China and anticipated liquidation of Tianjin Zerust, partially offset by decreases in expenses in North America due to companywide cost-cutting initiative. As a percentage of sales, operating expenses were 54.1% in fiscal 2016 third quarter compared to 57.7% in the same period last fiscal year. Overall, NTIC's reported net income attributed to NTIC of $917,000 or $0.20 per diluted share for the third quarter of fiscal 2016 compared to net income attributable to NTIC of $905,000 or $0.20 per diluted share during the third quarter of fiscal 2015. As of May 31, 2016, our working capital was $18.4 million including 4.6 million in cash and cash equivalents and $2.6 million in available for sale securities compared to $15.6 million including $2.6 million in cash and cash equivalents and $2 million in available for sale securities as of August 31, 2015. It's also important to point out that in May 31, 2016, the company had $18,600,000 of investments in joint ventures of which approximately 55% is in cash with the remaining balance is invested in working capital. Turning now to NTIC's annual guidance. As we mentioned in this morning press release, for the fiscal year ending August 31, 2016, we expect sales to be at the lower end of our previous guidance range of between $34 million to $37 million. As a result, we also anticipate net income attributable to NTIC to be at the lower end of our previous guidance range between 2 million and 3.2 million or between $0.40 and $0.70 per diluted share. This large range of guidance is due to the significant risks and uncertainties facing our business, including without limitation, the risks and uncertainties related to the change in our China operations, pending litigation, and other risks and uncertainties. With that update, we will now answer any questions you may have.
Operator
[Operator Instructions]. Our first question comes from Tim Clarkson of Van Clemens. Your line is now open.
Tim Clarkson
Hi, guys, great quarter. Just wanted to get some background on the two new areas a little bit. First of all, on the compostable line of business, where geographically in the United States are you seeing the strength and what are the attributes of your product that sort of differentiates you from the competition?
Patrick Lynch
Good morning, Tim. Well, our primary market still happens to be on the West Coast; so Washington, Oregon, and California. There are two categories of products obviously, the cutlery we are selling as well as the bags and the resin systems. Generally, our bags we believe are stronger mechanically and cheaper to produce than the competition, so we’re providing a better product at a competitive price. And our cutlery as opposed to competitive alternatives is truly compostable while having excellent heat deflection capabilities. So you can use our spoons and our forks and knifes in hot foods and beverages without them melting on you which is a problem that other competitors face.
Tim Clarkson
Are the customers echoing your voice about that, or is it starting to resonate with the customers saying that about your products?
Patrick Lynch
Yes, and actually after I think a seven-year trial period, we’re now at least being adopted on a limited basis in a large national fast food chain.
Tim Clarkson
Super. On the oil and gas end, how much of an issue is just the fact that it’s a new process and is there kind of a change in terms of the mindset of people realizing that the product really works, and it’s not that difficult to add to their process? Just how is that going?
Patrick Lynch
Well, we continue to get repeat orders from core customers. We also, as I mentioned earlier on the call, just got our first order from a global oil company for installation in a country we hadn’t done business before.
Tim Clarkson
Can you mention that country or --?
Patrick Lynch
I would prefer not to.
Tim Clarkson
Okay.
Patrick Lynch
But again I think that we’re getting a lot of positive feedback from customers in terms of performances of our solutions to the point where they are making presentations, raving about the results they’ve had with our products at technical conferences. So I think we’ve started to make some significant headway and that things should become progressively easier for us to penetrate this market more broadly going forward.
Tim Clarkson
Okay.
Patrick Lynch
Assuming oil prices are flat rating.
Tim Clarkson
Right, well, sure. Okay, well, I may come back but excellent quarter and glad to see Northern Tech back on track. It’s my favorite micro-cap, so I’ve high expectations for you guys. Thanks.
Patrick Lynch
We know. Thanks, Tim.
Operator
Thank you. Our next question comes from Scott Billeadeau of Walrus Partners. Your line is now open.
Scott Billeadeau
Good morning, guys. Just wanted to reiterate, was the guidance for fiscal – I’m trying to remember – your expectations for the next quarter should be pretty significant even to make the low end. If I’m kind of doing my math right, it should be what, $10 million or $11 million quarter, is that correct?
Matt Wolsfeld
That’s correct.
Scott Billeadeau
Okay, good, so all right. And same question, any – I came on to the call just a few minutes, I didn’t know if you had any updates on where the different legal battles are at this point?
Patrick Lynch
The legal battles in China are progressing at a pace of continental drift, so very slowly. With respect to the case in the United States, discovery including depositions are supposed to be concluded by the end of August, early September. If that doesn’t lead to a settlement, then the trial date will be I’m told sometime in March of next year.
Scott Billeadeau
Okay, great. And then just a followup on the oil and gas business. Is there much visibility, I know you kind of have an issue when the ground’s frozen given kind of the liquid aspect of one of your process. Can you maybe give us a little update on what you see now and how much visibility do you have if much at all in terms of implementations and what that looks like for the next quarter?
Patrick Lynch
Again, as I mentioned during the call, we just had sales with $300,000 in June which was quite significant for us. So at least for the next – for right now, we’re quite busy doing the installations. We’re still trying to finalize what we can still manage to ship and install for July and August, and thereafter we still have projects we are hoping to close and install certainly through the end of this calendar year.
Scott Billeadeau
Okay, all right. And just one other question for Matt. You mentioned $18 million and that’s in cash or in capital. There isn’t anything else really carried on the balance sheet in terms of what the joint ventures are in terms of the value of them. Is that correct? It’s essentially the cash held over there plus the working capital there. Is that pretty much it yet?
Matt Wolsfeld
Correct. They all have similar balance sheets to ours that tend to be very working capital heavy with very few if any long-time liabilities and none of them have any debt.
Scott Billeadeau
Yes, and like I say, you’re not carrying anything. Well, gee, if that was the company, what would the value of it be that we own X-percent of it? It’s just purely the cash and the working capital.
Matt Wolsfeld
Correct.
Scott Billeadeau
So fairly conservative of the balance sheet, great. All right, guys, thanks.
Operator
Thank you. [Operator Instructions]. Our next question comes from Dick Feldman of Axiom Capital. Your line is now open.
Dick Feldman
Good morning, guys. When you spoke about the losses in China, does that include the losses in operating income or are you just focusing on the one-time legal costs?
Matt Wolsfeld
No, those include the total – where we talk about the $1.4 million losses that we sustained in China. That takes into account the – if you’re looking at the subsidiary’s profit and loss statement for the year-to-date, that shows about an $800,000 loss. And then if you add on to that, you have a little more than the $600,000 of expenses that NTIC has incurred in North America related to litigation that is impacted by the Chinese operations and also by the increase in expense that we incur through selling, general and administrative expenses in support of that Chinese business. So just looking at the total expense related to China, the company is at a net loss for the nine months of a little over $1.4 million.
Dick Feldman
What would the operating --?
Matt Wolsfeld
Sorry.
Dick Feldman
What would the operating losses for the third quarter and you said you hoped be at breakeven levels by the end of the fiscal year, is that correct?
Matt Wolsfeld
Certainly on a monthly run rate given where sales are headed, we want China to be as a standalone – if you look at the standalone monthly financial statements, want them to be profitable.
Dick Feldman
The operating losses during the third quarter?
Matt Wolsfeld
The operating losses in the third quarter – I don’t have the number exactly in front of me. I only have the nine-month numbers in front of me of just under $800,000 in losses. I want to say it was a couple hundred thousand dollars in losses during the third quarter.
Dick Feldman
Okay, that’s close enough and hopefully will be going away.
Matt Wolsfeld
It’s certainly been going down if you look at the – when I look at the quarterly trend line of losses in China, it’s certainly been going down on a quarter-by-quarter basis.
Dick Feldman
In your guidance for the final quarter of the year, what do you anticipate in legal costs as you enter the discovery process for litigation in the U.S.?
Matt Wolsfeld
Well, we’re at a run rate depending on the month somewhere between $30,000 to $50,000 per month of legal expenses in North America related to the litigation in China.
Dick Feldman
But will the costs rise dramatically with the discovery?
Matt Wolsfeld
We’re pretty much through discovery. We’re on to other stages in the --
Patrick Lynch
I think at this point interrogatories, documents have been produced, several depositions have already been taken. So we still have some more depositions to conclude but it’s --
Matt Wolsfeld
I would imagine it would be pretty consistent with that amount.
Dick Feldman
Okay.
Patrick Lynch
I don’t anticipate any huge spike in legal expenses in fourth quarter that we didn’t see in second or third quarter to put it that way.
Dick Feldman
Okay. Do you have any sense as to whether you can – after this discovery whether you can settle?
Patrick Lynch
That all depends on the other side.
Dick Feldman
Okay. The R&D expenses risen moderately, is there any particular focus for this rise?
Patrick Lynch
As far as which new products we are working on or the overall R&D --?
Dick Feldman
Yes, it’s not a big rise.
Patrick Lynch
Yes, in general, the majority of the expense we have associated with R&D and for the most part selling and G&A is usually a function of employees and the number of people employed in that area. So there hasn’t been a significant flux in the number of people as far as the R&D department goes. It’s not as if all of a sudden in one quarter we’re placing a lot of – a huge amount of expense on developing one specific new product or something like that. There is no correlation like that. But the company’s certainly working on several new products in each area and also product improvements in each area whether it be oil and gas, Natur-Tec or the traditional ZERUST product line. And so I anticipate the R&D spending to stay pretty consistent with where it’s been.
Dick Feldman
Okay. Just eyeballing it looks like it’s up 10% or so.
Patrick Lynch
I would say that as we start to – as the product lines, being the oil and gas product line and the Natur-Tec product line move into profitability, they certainly had what I would refer to previously as business development expenses over the past eight, nine years that would from our characterization of expense standpoint would most likely starting in 2017 would be moved up to traditional SG&A expense, as those two entities are profitable. So I would say that in our fiscal 2017, I would expect the amount that are included in the R&D line to decrease but it would just be a matter of assigning that to the SG&A process above it.
Dick Feldman
Okay, great. So it’s --
Matt Wolsfeld
I would expect fourth quarter R&D numbers to be consistent with third quarter or even an average between second and third quarter.
Dick Feldman
And then one last question and that is what have you found to be the greatest impediment in your tank bottom business to a more rapid acceptance?
Patrick Lynch
I think that while we have proven that the product provides protection, warranted in the short term certainly for the first few years and as I mentioned before on the call that we had satisfied customers publishing technical papers citing their results, I think some of these larger customers are still reasonably cautious and they’re willing to implement it on a certain set of tanks until they have first five years’ worth of data. And then we would expect an uptick. So since we’ve been now doing this slightly over two years, I think we’re going to continue to be on one growth pace for the next two and a half years and then see a more rapid rise after that.
Dick Feldman
Okay. So it takes – so until we get that five-year anniversary, the orders will likely be more modest in scale; onesie, twosie, let’s try it?
Patrick Lynch
There’s not a fixed timeline but that’s my anticipation. It could happen sooner that than.
Dick Feldman
Okay. Thanks for taking my questions and lots of moving pieces but totally looks good.
Patrick Lynch
Thanks.
Operator
Thank you. Our next question comes from Joe Furst of Furst Associates. Your line is now open.
Joe Furst
Good morning, gentlemen. Good quarter. I appreciate your good work. The person two persons ago made the point that I wanted to make about even if you only had the lower end of your previous estimate of earnings, it would be a $0.27 quarter which would be better than this quarter. So you certainly are improving dramatically – drastically rather. And the question I had, what’s the nature of your competition in China? Can you expand upon that a little bit?
Patrick Lynch
I would guess that there are two levels of competition in China. You have other corrosion inhibiting solution providers that operate in multiple countries that are basically I guess tapping the high end of the market. And then you have a set of very low cost domestic suppliers that again go after the low end of the market. But I would say in total there are certainly – in excess of 10 companies that are competing for this business. And it is quite an aggressive complex market.
Joe Furst
Okay, thank you. And also I wanted to compliment you for hiring an Investor Relations type person to help get your story out because you certainly have a good story to tell. That was a good thing to do. Thank you and keep up the good work.
Patrick Lynch
Thank you.
Operator
Thank you. Your next question comes from Jerry Well, a private investor. Your line is now open.
Unidentified Analyst
Good morning, guys. Congratulations on the quarter. My question relates to this service agreement that you signed with your – I presume the same partner you’ve been partnering with before with the tank business. Just kind of curious what drove the signing of one more agreement? Was that driven by you, by them and I wanted to see how you see that impacting revenue growth in that area with them and also gross margins? So that’s one question. And then the second question is just if you have any additional product rollouts over the next 12 months that you haven’t announced yet that you may or may not have and you have anything to share on that would be appreciated?
Patrick Lynch
Sure. Yes, it is the same partner we were talking about before. I believe that this is based on mutual respect in terms of what each side has to offer in terms of building sales and market share. So our solutions are being viewed as very attractive addition to distribution partners’ portfolio of solutions that they think they can market profitably. In terms of impact on margins, I think our margins are just fine even under this model. And what was the second part of your question?
Unidentified Analyst
Well, I’m curious how it impacts in your selling other places, into other channels if you will in the U.S.? It sounds like they are a U.S. based company. I don’t know if they sell overseas also but just in the agreement does it give them exclusive distribution to certain states or certain niches? I’m just curious how it, without getting into legalities.
Patrick Lynch
It basically makes them, we prefer solution implementer, but it’s not entirely exclusive. And in terms of other products, we continue to introduce new products in various applications and countries. We have been talking about them openly because we certainly anticipate that the ramp up cycle much likely shown with tank bottoms can be quite slow. And until we gain significant traction in them, we’ll kind of just monitor them as a sideline rather than basically [indiscernible] into the market just yet.
Unidentified Analyst
Okay, all right. And back to – thanks for that information. Back to the agreement then, you don’t anticipate probably much of a difference in revenue increase with this signed distribution agreement as compared to how you’ve been doing business with them in the past, but just more formalizing it?
Patrick Lynch
I think we’re going to see the biggest pickup really once we hit 2017. Right now we’re working on more broadly educating their sales staff and training them on how to really offer the solution. And they’re also figuring out how to best market it within their network. So we really anticipate that things will pick up in 2017 in that regard.
Unidentified Analyst
Okay, thanks a lot guys and as far as the lawsuits they are a pain in the fanny but you guys did the right thing and that’s the important thing. Long term, it will work out fine. So thanks guys for a good quarter.
Patrick Lynch
Thanks. I appreciate that.
Operator
Thank you. Our next question comes from Greg Weaver of Invicta. Your line is now open.
Greg Weaver
Hi. Good morning. Just following up on the line of questioning there. On the implementation of oil and gas, I guess is there a bottleneck there, because you mentioned, Patrick, about you guys really busy with the 300,000 orders that you got during the prior month?
Patrick Lynch
I don’t think it’s a bottleneck, it’s just the question of shipping product, getting into the destination, at the destination site making sure that all of the other preparatory work is being done on time. So I don’t think there’s anything impeding us. None of our resource is impeding the installation. But even in the summer time you never know what the weather is going to be or what – actually one of our installations when you have that big map of fire in Canada just a month or two ago, that delayed an installation by over a month. So sometimes we’re subject to acts of God.
Greg Weaver
Right. So the point being I guess if the orders went up to 500,000 a month that’s not an issue for you guys but all this stuff can happen to actually get that ruled out?
Patrick Lynch
We can produce the product, we can ship the product, we can get everything staged on site and then just regular construction associated delays can slow down the implementation, but we should – between us and our distribution partner we have certainly enough technical resources to oversee the installation in a timely manner.
Greg Weaver
Right, the technical oversight was kind of where I was going, okay. And then I guess just Matt, so – in fact to the couple prior questions about the revenue in the current quarter of 11 million-ish, is there any particular driver there or is just everything going up or what should we think about there?
Matt Wolsfeld
In general we tend to have a stronger third and fourth quarter but just looking forward at the results we already have from June, we’re already – I want to say we’re already $600,000 ahead of where we finished – when we were one month into third quarter, we were already $600,000 ahead of that. All the different carriers that we have are picking up and we certainly anticipate a strong fourth quarter. And that’s why we’re able to maintain the guidance and that’s why we’re – I certainly hope that we, and with where I’m looking at the numbers for all the different business units, why we still would be able to come in at the low end of our sales guidance.
Greg Weaver
Got you, okay, sounds good. And obviously with more oil and gas in there, I assume the nice gross margins you had in the current quarter ought to be sustainable?
Matt Wolsfeld
I certainly hope so.
Greg Weaver
Okay.
Matt Wolsfeld
I don’t see a reason why gross margin would change between third quarter and fourth quarter, put it that way.
Greg Weaver
Great. And Natur-Tec, where are we at there in terms of standalone profitability?
Patrick Lynch
Well, May was the first month in the history of the company where Natur-Tec was profitable in our significant milestone. Their monthly average run rate has certainly spiked over the past – I look back on a monthly run rate this year, it certainly has ramped up now into the mid $400,000 monthly levels, which is good and it’s where we wanted the company to be from Natur-Tec standpoint to be profitable. They’ve got an awful lot of potential and Greg as you’re well aware it’s probably the opportunities and it looks like they just keep on, on a monthly basis adding and adding to their base business as a consumable with solid repeat orders. So Natur-Tec is going strong and certainly we’re happy from a company standpoint to cross the threshold and start making money on that product line.
Greg Weaver
Yes, it’s worth mentioning. Must have been 10 years or so now on the other side.
Patrick Lynch
It’s going to take more than a month or two to dig out of the hole of everything we’ve spent over the last nine years, but it certainly still – it’s significant from our standpoint of getting to a point where we’re generating something out of Natur-Tec, because we know that long term Natur-Tec is a business and Natur-Tec – as far as what it’s doing from a compostability standard and everything that’s going on worldwide with the concerns over plastic that it’s a business that we want to be in. And certainly what we’ve been able to do as far as being one of the pioneers in the industry with the cutting-edge technology and the people that we are partnering with as far as utilization of the base resins from Nature Works and other companies, it’s certainly – it appears that the company is positioned well in Natur-Tec to continue the growth that we’ve seen if you look back over a three-year run rate, it’s been a pretty significant consistent build of sales.
Greg Weaver
Very good. And the opportunity for bulk resin sales have kind of still – not much activity there.
Patrick Lynch
There’s certainly more activity. We’re selling bulk now out of our subsidiary in India and also out of the United States. It doesn’t pick up, it’s still measured in a few containers per month, but still it’s picking up bit by bit.
Greg Weaver
Okay, great. Well congrats especially on the breakeven in Natur-Tec, so glad we’re on the right path there. Thanks.
Patrick Lynch
Thanks, Greg.
Operator
Thank you. I’m showing no further questions at this time. I would like to turn the conference back over to Mr. Lynch for any closing remarks.
Patrick Lynch
I’d like to thank everyone for participating today and your interest in NTIC. Have a great day. Thank you.
Operator
Ladies and gentlemen, thank you for participating in today’s conference. This does conclude the program and you may all disconnect. Have a great day everyone.