The Gap, Inc.

The Gap, Inc.

$24.87
2.83 (12.84%)
New York Stock Exchange
USD, US
Apparel - Retail

The Gap, Inc. (GAP) Q3 2016 Earnings Call Transcript

Published at 2016-11-17 21:47:06
Executives
Jack Calandra - SVP, Corporate Finance and IR Arthur Peck - CEO Sabrina Simmons - EVP and CFO
Analysts
Adrienne Yih - Wolfe Research Lindsay Drucker Mann - Goldman Sachs. Matthew Boss - JPMorgan Susan Anderson - FBR Capital Markets Ike Boruchow - Wells Fargo Brian Tunick - Royal Bank of Canada Lorraine Hutchinson - Bank of America Randy Konik - Jeffries Dana Telsey - Telsey Advisory Group Oliver Chen - Cowen and Company
Operator
Good afternoon, ladies and gentlemen. My name is Lisa and I will be your conference operator today. At this time, I would like to welcome everyone to the Gap Inc. Third Quarter 2016 Conference Call. At this time, all participants are in a listen-only mode. [Operator Instructions] I would now like to introduce your host, Jack Calandra, Senior Vice President of Corporate Finance and Investor Relations. Please go ahead sir.
Jack Calandra
Before we begin, I'd like to remind you that the information made available on this webcast and conference call contains forward-looking statements. For information on factors that could cause our actual results to differ materially from the forward-looking statements as well as reconciliations and descriptions of non-GAAP financial measures, as noted on page two of the slides supplementing Sabrina's remarks, please refer to today's earnings press release as well as our most recent Annual Report on Form 10-K and our subsequent filings with the SEC, all of which are available on gapinc.com. These forward-looking statements are based on information as of November 17th, 2016, and we assume no obligation to publicly update or revise our forward-looking statements. Joining me on the call today are CEO, Art Peck; and Executive Vice President and CFO, Sabrina Simmons. As I mentioned, Sabrina will be using slides to supplement her remarks, which you can view by going to the Investors section at gapinc.com. With that, I'd like to turn the call over to Art.
Arthur Peck
Thanks, Jack, and good afternoon to everyone. I’m going to talk as I have in all of the calls that we’ve had really about both the long game and the short game. And let me start continuing to address the strategy and many of the things that I’ve been talking to you about and give you an update on where we are there, but then also obviously a deeper dive into Q3 and the prospects that I see as we look into this holiday period and Q4. We are – I would say well into transforming and re-building parts of this company, starting with our product model. And I’ve talked to you about the work that we’ve been doing to enhance our responsiveness across all of our brands in key categories to pivot towards a much more continuous and demand based buying process to test our products in advance of the buys that we are placing to go into season open etcetera and continue to be pleased with the progress that we are making, but also acknowledging the fact that this is a journey and there remains significant work in front of us. First and foremost we need to win on product. And as I look into Q4, I am feeling very good about the product that we have in our stores across all of our brands. Obviously the consumers will tell us how well we are doing and how well we did with the products after we hindsight the season, but if I look across all of the businesses I feel like we are in the best place that we’ve been now for several seasons where we are lined up against trend where we have consistent quality appropriate to the brands, where we’ve gotten our fit dialled into the point where it is consistent and where each brand is showing up expressing the DNA and the finger prints of the brand. The second thing that I’ve talked about is the fact that we are hedged down focus on ringing every penny out of the places where we have scale advantage. And that is obviously both on the product side of the equation but on the several billion dollars elsewhere in the company where we purchase a wide variety of things. And that is work that is not done, but it is work that is significantly under way and again work that I think has very significant pay off over the medium term. The third thing that I have spent time talking about is the innovation in products. And again, we are in the early days of innovation in the ready-to-wear space but already there is good evidence of how we can cross [Indiscernible] innovation from the active side of the business into the ready-to-wear business and create meaningful benefits and have consumers connect with those product benefits in our ready-to-wear product. A good example of this is the Sculptek product that Athleta introduced a few months ago, performing very well in Athleta stores as a compression shaping product. It’s also a proprietary fiber and now we are moving to pull that into other bottoms fabrications including denim and to all fabrications. And the properties that that allows us to deliver in what is a traditional denim fabrication were actually quite extraordinary. And so as we get this up in running, I am continuing to be very encouraged by how our consumers are responding to it, how we are delivering things beyond just trend to make the benefits of that product very meaningful to them. Demand-base buying is a critical piece, and again to refresh your perspective we and many others have traditionally bought the year one season on a grand reveal at a time. And that means making large commitments well in advance of when the product is going to be in the store and well in advance of knowing what the consumer really wants. So as we have been building the responsive supply chain capabilities, we have been also been re-engineering the front end of the business, so that we can buy on a much more continuous basis in many cases every month versus on a quarterly basis. And again, this brings several benefits. We remain open as we get closer to the season and can pivot to buy it to the most meaningful trends and fabrications, but also we are delivering newness constantly into our stores which we know that our customers respond to. Outside of the product initiatives, we've also talked about CRM and about the customer and about data and about personalization and about technology. And we're not letting up on the throttle as we go after those areas as well. And you may have noted that in the last few months I created a new role in the company led by a chief customer officer who also has strategy, and that's really focused on bringing together every aspect of the customer across data, consumer insights, digital touch touch points and in-store experiences to create a holistic 360 view of the customer from which we can deliver meaningful benefits to that customer whether their benefits around loyalty, around personalization, rounded in-store experience a digital experience. Mobile obviously remains incredibly important and we continue to see customers move from a desktop or a laptop experience to not just doing business on their mobile device, but really engaging the brand on their mobile device. And as a consequence, we continue to put aggressive effort against the mobile space, some of it is just the basics, but really important basics like continuing to improve site speed, how fast our pages load, allowing the mobile site to process a variety of forms of rich content that the consumer increasingly expects to have, we see mobile as fundamentally where our consumer starts and often times ends their journey and we need to make sure that we have a mobile experience that is commensurate with every other quality touch point that we have with our brands. Let me move to China for a second, because it's fresh in my mind as I came back from a trip there just a week ago. I am very bullish on the long-term opportunity in China and while I will acknowledge that the fact that the economy has cooled somewhat, and the consumer is a little more cautious there, has probably impacted everybody's business it has not impacted my enthusiasm for the long-term potential in that market. We executed a strategy and Old Navy a couple of years ago, where we put in place a number of stores across different types of locations, different store sizes, and we've been working that footprint now for the last several months in order to refine the four wall model. Secondly, obviously Gap was the business that we planted their first both in the specialty stores and the Gap factory stores. And we continue to see that the customer resonates to that brand and wants to participate in that brand. And third, the Chinese consumer is fundamentally an omni-channel consumer, and I remained very enthusiastic around an online business that is a significant penetration into the retail business and has very attractive economics. A moment on Q3, and obviously Sabrina will take you deeper into the numbers. First of all I'd say the retail environment, the apparel environment continues to be challenging. Traffic remains challenging and as a planning assumption, we believe that will carry forward as well. We feel that it's appropriate to plan for that obviously we're doing work to try to beat that trend, but we understand the fact that traffic is likely to continue to be challenging as we look forward. Given that, I'm actually pretty pleased with Q3, because I see positive momentum even against the backdrop of the Fishkill fire. And I won't go into the details of Fishkill, I will say just as a call out that I felt like our logistics team in this company did an extraordinary job of not missing a beat from the standpoint of rewiring our logistics network with our facility in the middle of the country and our facility on the west coast and continuing to keep supply going into our stores on a very cost efficient fashion. A quick perspective on Q4. I believe that I said before, that we are well setup from the standpoint of the product in the assortment, just as a side bar again, we continue to move the needle in terms of customer reported experience with fit and quality, which had been very intentional initiatives. I believe, we've taken another step forward in the back half of the year and into Q4 on both of these dimensions. We're also putting marketing into the business in a way that we haven't over the last couple of years, with marketing both in BR and in Gap, including TV for Gap. And I'm excited because now is a time when we need to start filling the funnel with laps customers and new customers in order to buck the negative traffic trend. And well I've mentioned BR and Gap in terms of marketing; of course Old Navy is lined up as they always are in Q4 with a strong marketing program including the $100,000 a day giveaway for eight days. So brand by brand, just a few comments. With Gap, right direction continuing to show stronger women's performance so I like to call out, because I -- the core of that business obviously needs to be a strong women's business. In the kids assortment, we have a significant expression of licensed product, I'm very excited about, we have not done a large licensing business and particularly in Q4 we feel that has a lot of relevance. Old Navy, I think the numbers frankly speak for themselves, an excellent Q3 and an exciting holiday campaign, strong marketing, I think if you walk into an Old Navy store right now and I've spent a lot of time in those stores all around the country and all around the world, you will see incredible clarity of product message, you will see clear, category presentations there are super easy to shop, that's the feedback that we get from our customer. You know the work that's been going on in Banana, on quality and on aesthetic. Customer feedback is that both are significantly moving in the right direction. We have a holiday campaign, including a catalog, which we have not done for years that is focused on reaching lapsed customers and new customers. And we believe we're set up to continue the improvement of the business there that we're seeing. Athleta, I have nothing but good things to say quite honestly, positioned obviously against a very strong trend that continues to have legs underneath it. And again, Athleta is an active business. Athleta is also a lifestyle business, and that's really the core of Athleta positioning that confluence of active and lifestyle, which their customers very much respond to. I haven't spoken about marketing in Athleta. We have a very connected customer there, the holiday campaign, share your light is a campaign that is focused on strong community engagement, which is really a place of strength for them. I expect Athleta to carry their momentum into Q4. I expect Athleta to continue to perform as we get into next year as well. Again, that confluence of lifestyle and performance is powerful. Before I close, I'd like to acknowledge the announcement that we made a couple of weeks ago about Sabrina Simmons leaving the Company and then just a few days ago about Teri List-Stoll joining as CFO. First on Teri, I’ve spent quite a bit of time getting to know her, time in stores, time with product, time across a variety of places in the business. And I'm really excited about her joining the team and the perspective that she brings from her experience. We’ll obviously get more time to get to know her, some of you may know her already, but I'm very excited about having her on the team and looking forward to her joining in January. Let me turn the Sabrina. She will be missed. I'm sure missed by you and most certainly missed by me, and the team here. She's been an incredible partner to me. In her nine years as CFO, she has obviously been very passionate about our capital structure, about our investment thesis, and just an incredible contributor to the company and in our relationships with the investment community. In 15 years at the company, she's done nothing but perform in an exemplary fashion in every role. And so I will miss her, I want to thank her, I'm very appreciative that she will be here until the end of the fiscal year to facilitate a very orderly and structured transition, and with that Sabrina let me turn it over to you.
Sabrina Simmons
Thanks so much for your generous comments, Art. It's been a great 15-year run and a true privilege to serve the Company and our shareholders. Now moving on to third quarter performance. Sales totaled $3.8 billion, down 2% versus last year. Comp sales were down 3%. We were pleased that third quarter gross margin was up 200 basis points over last year largely driven by Old Navy. Merchandised margins expanded 220 basis points and rent occupancy deleverage 20 basis points. Moving to expenses, third quarter total operating expenses were up $78 million to $1.1 billion, including about $35 million related to restructuring charges. Marketing expenses were up $6 million to a $148 million. Regarding taxes, our reported effective tax rate was 45.2% the higher rate was driven by the impact from our restructuring actions, primarily in Japan. Our adjusted effective tax rate was about five percentage points lower. Turning to earnings, on a reported basis, earnings per share were $0.51. The non tax-related restructuring costs were about $30 million in the quarter, this brings our year-to-date non-tax related restructuring costs to about a $180 million. Excluding the tax and non-tax impact of restructuring, our adjusted earnings per share were $0.60. Regarding the balance sheet and cash flow, we ended the third quarter with inventory down 4% year-over-year. We expect total inventory dollars at the end of the fourth quarter to be down low single-digits year-over-year. Our year-to-date free cash flow was an inflow of over $415 million. Regarding capital expenditures and square footage, year-to-date capital expenditures were $383 million versus $505 million last year. Square footage was down 2% compared with last year. With regard to our outlook for the remainder of the year we are reaffirming our full-year adjusted earnings per share guidance range of 187 to 192 excluding restructuring costs. A few things to note about the assumptions around our guidance. First for published reports industry traffic has decelerated November month-to-date. Second is Art mentioned given that challenging traffic trends have continued we are investing meaningfully in marketing across our portfolio of brands during the holiday season. We are not necessarily expecting an immediate payback from these investments, but consider them to be important for the longer term health of the business. Additionally we are lapping bonus reversals last year which are also a headwind to Q4 expense. Therefore we expect SG&A to de-leverage in the fourth quarter and for the full year. Third, we expect rent and occupancy to be more pressured in the fourth quarter due to pre-opening costs associated with our time square flagship locations for both Gap and Old Navy scheduled to open in the back half of 2017. Given all of these factors we continue to feel our guidance represents a prudent range. Regarding other guidance metrics we expect the negative impact from the fire at our distribution center to be just over one comp point in the fourth quarter. Similar to Q3 the impact will be highest at Gap brand and lowest at Old Navy regarding square footage we now expect to end the year down 3%, a reduction from our earlier guidance of down two driven by additional gap store closures. Regarding our restructuring costs we now estimate the full year impacted between $0.42 and $0.46 down from our previous estimate of $0.45 to $0.50. All other full year guidance metrics remain substantially unchanged. Thank you. And now I'll turn it back over to Jack.
Jack Calandra
That concludes our prepared remarks. We will now open up the call to questions. We'd appreciate limiting your questions to one per person.
Operator
[Operator Instructions] We will take our first question today from Adrienne Yih, Wolfe Research.
Adrienne Yih
Good afternoon. Nice top on the third quarter, Sabrina you'll be greatly missed and when you've been a great steward of the company, but even better you've been a great person to work with, so I just want to say that.
Sabrina Simmons
Thanks.
Adrienne Yih
Art, this is the question for you. I wanted to know what your thoughts are about that much talk about denim cycle, how you can play that at the Gap brand and when you might see a kind of some real impetus behind that that cycle becoming more prominent. And then for Sabrina actually you know with the loss of the unit have you thought about the business as you plan for next year and whether you could and should be running with far fewer units in order to get better gross margin dollars? Thank you so much.
Arthur Peck
Thank you. And I couldn't agree more first of all with your comments about Sabrina. I could talk a lot longer about that, but I know you have some specific questions. The denim cycle I would say is its clearly hit bottom and down stuff we've talked about that. It is an important part of what we're seeing at Old Navy right now and continuing to power the performance, and then it's important part increasingly important part of Bananas business and Gap's business as well. It's not as consistent as I would hope it is and I see that across the whole industry right now. It is clearly she's refreshing her closet but it's still not a strong dominant trend with super news out there. Obviously with Gap will focus on that. Stretch in across all fabrications across the entire family of something that were rapidly ramping up both in the kids business as well as the adult business. But we're hoping there is more in front of us because it hasn't really hit our view that you know turn up inflection point where it's really starting to power the business right now. Sabrina, I'll turn it over to you.
Sabrina Simmons
Yes. With regard to inventory, as tragic as the fire was, there were some really important lessons for us and that and one of them for sure Adrian is you know just when you think you're already running tight that you can actually run tighter and bring those that margin rate up in the margin dollars. So, sure as we look into next year we're trying to incorporate that lesson. Now Q4 was obviously bought, most of spring bought, but as we look forward to summer fall and you know holiday 2017, I know the teams are really embracing the lessons from this fall and holiday, and very much are aligned in looking to continue to survive units very tightly. Now that said, you don't want to get so draconian that you don't give yourself an opportunity to positive comp. So are we walking that tightrope? But yes for sure it has been a really, really good lesson.
Adrienne Yih
Okay. Fair enough. Best of luck for holiday.
Arthur Peck
Thank you.
Operator
Next up, we'll hear from Lindsay Drucker Mann, Goldman Sachs.
Lindsay Drucker Mann
Thanks. Good afternoon and Sabrina also you will be missed. Moving on to my questions, I wanted to ask about the merchandise margin improvement in the third quarter and how we should be thinking about the opportunity that sequential opportunities in 4Q, in other words do you see as much opportunity for merchandise margin recovery in 4Q as you had in the third quarter? And then, secondly on SG&A, you had a bigger increase in the third quarter than we were expecting. Does that reflect some of those initial marketing initiatives that you talk about that impacting on the fourth quarter and maybe giving us some perspective on what type of marketing you plan to invest in? Thanks.
Sabrina Simmons
Sure. So, starting with the margin, we were obviously very pleased with the Q3 results. A couple of things to point out in terms of differences between Q3 and Q4 Lindsay, as we all know Q4 tends to be much more promotional and competitive than Q3, and then this Q3 of course was unique because we lost a lot of units in the fire, a lot of those units were fall fashion, so we were super tight on fashion in Q3 and that likely supported the nice outcome on margin. In contract in Q4 we didn't lose any holiday fashion and threw it in the fire, so we still have basic and seasonal basics that were lost and supposed to be sold, but none of our holiday in any meaningful way was lost. So we have more passion in Q4 than we had Q3. Now if traffic improved and we move the unit as expected the time we wanted and the velocity we wanted then all is going to be well. But as we mentioned traffic has started out sort of stubborn and still challenge. And so I just sort of feel like given the fact is too early to get overly optimistic. Although, obviously the teams will be driving toward that some improvement year-over-year, so that's the margin peace. With regard to the expense piece, there's lots of moving parts and expense. Marketing was actually only up 6 million and there were a bunch of other components some of which are investments for the long term that the company has decided to make. Art mentioned for example the whole customer states and hiring a Chief Customer Officer and what comes with that. So, we are starting to invest them. And then as I've been talking about for some time since we're laughing many years of very tight expense management that it really gets super task to try and leverage unless you have a very solid positive com. Art, do you want to?
Arthur Peck
I think that pretty much said it all. We can provide more detail and marketing and probably not just to go into all the right now, but guess back on TV for the first time and it's significant TV presence we have a catalogue behind the Banana business, it's dropping right now. I walked out of the train station this morning to see a transit take over here which we're doing in a number of markets, so it is a it is a significant uptick in marketing. And as we said don't -- hope certainly we get an immediate return, but we're not assuming that the case because we got to get the flywheel turning again.
Lindsay Drucker Mann
Great. Thanks so much.
Arthur Peck
Yes.
Operator
Next, we'll hear from Matthew Boss, JPMorgan.
Matthew Boss
Thanks. So just a lot of moving parts on the expense side into next year. I guess what what's the best way to think about timing and cadence of the expense save. And then just with wages and some of the investments offsetting part of this how should we think about overall SG&A dollars in terms of moving forward?
Sabrina Simmons
Yes. I'm not going to get into 2017 too much, Matt, because of course I'll leave that to my successor, but I'll tell you remind kind of the actions we took this year and the shapes that it should take. So the actions we took, we said, should result in annualized SG&A savings of $275 million. Some of that coming in 2016, but probably most of that coming in 2017. Now what we said at the time is again after years of very tight management part of the reason we chose to do that restructuring is because it would help offset some of the natural inflation that you get running our business and would allow us to continue to be discipline in our operating expenses. We are starting to make some decisions to make certain investments in the business. And I talked about one or two of those already in overhead and people in the form of people and also in marketing especially in Q4 and we will talk more or the team will talk more about what those investments look like as we move into 2017 on the Q4 call.
Matthew Boss
Got it. And then just follow-up. At the core cap what level of traffic you need to drive a potential positive comp and if you could just talk to some of the underlying trends that you're seeing beneath the surface, beneath the comp in terms of AUR traffic, know just any green shoots that you're seeing in some of the new product potentially?
Sabrina Simmons
Yes. We think when we started the year that we knew traffic wouldn't jump to positive. So we were kind of planning on a low single-digit negative and with that kind of number and a healthy AUR we could drive a positive comp. That was the plan. Unfortunately traffic has been more tending toward mid and high single negative digits, and that's really been difficult for us to get traction on. Art can talk more about what we see under the covers. But certainly encouraging to see that women as a year has progresses it has been stronger than men. Year-to-date margins overall have been helping it gap. So those are some of the signs but for sure the progress has been slower than any of us hope for. I don't know art if you want to add anything to that.
Arthur Peck
Yes. I would just say that the part of the silver lining such as there was of the unit side of the business is it allowed us to really demonstrate and validate the pricing authority of the brand as we've tightened up and not have to move that many more units against the higher-than-expected negative traffic tend, so it's actually given us pretty good validation of where we are from product standpoint. And then the other part of the validation is just the -- we have a close look to the process of understanding consumers perspectives on the product after they buy and the metrics there are moving quite nicely in the positive direction around fashion, around it and around quality. And so I'm cautiously optimistic obviously for bucking as a whole industry is overall a traffic trends in the mid to high single digits and that's a tough number to look at it from the standpoint of pulling out a positive comp against that.
Matthew Boss
Great. Best of luck.
Operator
[Operator Instructions] Your next question comes from the line of Susan Anderson, FBR Capital Markets.
Susan Anderson
Hi. Good evening. Thanks for taking my question. I was wondering if you could talk about the international business maybe just give us an update there. I know for a while Gap U.S, was outperforming the International, so just wondering about still the case if you've seen international turn a little bit better? Thanks/
Arthur Peck
Yes. I mean the international business is obviously a composite of a number of different markets which have a variety of things going on them. Probably the most consistent theme obviously has continued FX pressure there and gap is more exposed to that as you know than any other business. If you look across the key pieces of the portfolio for Gap brand you know the Japanese economy has obviously been challenging for everyone. We've seen some firming up of the business I'd describe recently but we have a long way to go there to get to the kind of performance we want to look at. I talked about China my remarks I don't really dwell on that, continue to be optimistic in the long run. but it's been I think probably the most promotional time we've seen in that market since we've been present with all relevant competitors both local and non-local breaking sail far earlier having sailed go deeper and longer than we previously experienced which indicates the miss balance of inventory and demand right now within that market. And then Europe continues to be Europe. We've announced obviously the actions that we've taken there in terms of closing some stores. We have a very good online business there, the specialty business obviously carries a very good online business there, the specialty business obviously carries a very significant blood on its P&L and that's been an issue we've had there for a long time. So it's a real mixed bag. And then in parts of the business in Canada, Canada has been very strong for us. Its been very good business, so it's really a function of which market you're looking at.
Susan Anderson
Great. Thanks. Very helpful. Good luck next quarter.
Arthur Peck
Thanks.
Operator
Our next question comes from Ike Boruchow, Wells Fargo.
Ike Boruchow
Hi everyone. Thanks for taking my question and congrats, Sabrina best of luck going forward. Just a question I guess, the profit plan next year's was asked about and I think you're exiting the Old Navy Japan business. Just curious when you look at your portfolio across all brands and all geographies, are there any other maybe geographies that aren't really hitting their ROI hurdle that maybe even eye on that maybe you know down the road over the next 12 --24 months the business might look to evaluate as well?
Arthur Peck
Yes. I would say that when we announced the actions that we took earlier this year, we try to really get at the things that we have line of sight to in terms of them not being strategic or not having a place to get to the kinds of returns that we wanted to see. So I cant preview any other significant things that I see in front of us. Obviously we're living in a very volatile time right now and we'll continue to re-evaluate this as we always do on an ongoing basis, but I would like to believe that we got at the great majority of the things we need to get to over the course of the actions we took this year.
Ike Boruchow
Great. Thank you.
Operator
Our next question will come from Brian Tunick, Royal Bank of Canada.
Brian Tunick
Thanks. Good afternoon. And Sabrina, we wish you all the best as well. I guess are two quick ones, just maybe on the supply chain if you could give us an update there on what metrics you're seeing to help us understand the progress and maybe how much open to buy you have this holiday versus last year and where do you expect that to go? And then secondly, on the share repurchase program it's been such a big part of the story over the last couple of years, so I know you still have some of that revolver outstanding, but has the philosophy changed regarding the company's capital allocation or minimum cash position? Thanks very much.
Arthur Peck
So, let me actually address the second one first. Our philosophy hasn't changed at all. We've communicated clearly on the loan that we have outstanding and flexibility there, but you've seen what we said about that before and nothing's really changed on that. We slow down this year obviously on share repurchases against the volatility of the backdrop and what was a challenging environment we just felt like that was the prudent thing to do. A policy of returning excess cash back to shareholders remains pretty much intact I would say no real change and no discussion about changing that. Right now we want to just make sure that we can maintain flexibility as we see and hopefully as traffic firms up et cetera and we see performance stabilize we get a sense of how the various things that are taking place in the world impact the marketplace we'll come back and look at that as we go forward. But I would say there's no fundamental change at all. We want to communicate with respect to our capital policy our cash balances or anything like that. Sabrina, do you want to add anything to that?
Sabrina Simmons
No.
Arthur Peck
Okay. I'm sorry. With that that brilliant explanation of supply chain yes, let me come back and talk a little bit about supply chain. We'd really and this is why I said in my last remarks maybe a quarter ago is that we are continuing to move down a path and I'm not going to go into a lot of specifics because it just it's really category by category, brand by brand, if you think about demand-based buying, if you think about the response of platform et cetera and so the answer can differ to. We're still buying one category on a traditional pipeline like outerwear, but in other categories like bottoms and mix, we have significantly improved the responsiveness of the category. We're making excellent progress and really more the challenge right now is the operating model of businesses and being able to exploit it demand-based buying as an example, we're building tools against that right now versus doing it by brute force. It's more about the front end of the business than really the back end of the business right now. So, I've been pleased with the progress that we've made in our supply chain facing our vendors, consolidating vendors, consolidating our best class platform in fabrics all those types of things and we're doing the front end work right now, but this again is this is a season-over-season thing and I am seeing material meaningful season-over-season advancement in terms of these capabilities. Operator, is there next question.
Operator
Yes. We'll take our next question from Lorraine Hutchinson, Bank of America.
Lorraine Hutchinson
Thank you. Good afternoon. Art you talked a little bit about the Gap brand and working on your pricing authority, I was just hoping for an update on how you view your current denim and tops prices at the Gap if you think you're at the right place and if any changes need to happen as you add more content to the product?
Arthur Peck
Yes. We're actually doing some pretty much, pretty deep work right now on pricing, so it's something that's really on my mind. We did some work at Old Navy which are now in the process of implementing which highlighted some pretty material opportunity and we're repeating that work inside of Gap around as well. I guess I'd highlight a couple of things if I look at denim. First of all, if you look at where we are from the standpoint of both our tickets and our actuals, we actually play in a pretty narrow range. If you think about denim where it is. Denim starts in an $8 entry-level price point all the way up to multiple hundreds of dollars. And we really across all of our brands are very tightly banded. So I think there is a breath of fabrication, good, better, best if you want to think about that way. The Gap has an opportunity to step up to in terms of product development. And that's probably the biggest on my mind right now. The second issue is we have seen where we've been able to have pricing authority, but it hasn't been consistent enough and that comes a bit with the quality of our buys and it comes I think with making sure again we're dialed in and on trend across the entire buy. I'm really focused on denim from a market share standpoint and that's how we're thinking about the company. And I've been very pleased with what I've seen it will maybe where we have been on a up consistent posture of gaining market share in denim. And down and we're doing the work both in Banana and Gap to make sure that those businesses are moving forward that way as well. Again if I reiterated probably the biggest opportunities I see it is the breadth of our development and therefore how straddle where demand sits in the marketplace right now from a price point standpoint, and we're pretty narrow relative to where I think we can play.
Lorraine Hutchinson
Thank you.
Operator
Our next question today will come from Randy Konik, Jeffries.
Randy Konik
Yes. Thanks a lot. Sabrina it's been great working with you all these years and I wish you nothing but the best. Actually have a question for you Sabrina, if you think about the merchandise margin improvement, I think you mentioned bulk of it was from Old Navy. Can you give us some a little perspective on where we are in perspective merchandise margin cycles of each division, trying to get some perspective on where we are versus peak, obviously if we can go back to peak where we are versus more normalized trend across three divisions, and when you look at the composition of inventory I believe down 4%. How does that composition look by division right now? Thanks.
Sabrina Simmons
Yes. So, on the margins I would say since we don't segment report Randy I'll try and get some color, but mostly keep it at the Gap Inc level. I would say that I'm if you exclude the impact of foreign exchange which has hurt us for the last several years especially Gap brand. If you exclude that we're actually not at horrible levels. We're not at peak levels. So we're not at horrible levels of merchandise margins. What I would tell you is that over the course of this year as you all know from comp reporting and our sales reporting, Banana has had the most pressure over the last little while. So directionally they're probably the furthest from peak and directionally Old Navy's probably the closest, as they've been recovering and having some good business. So hopefully that is helpful. With regards to inventory your question was around remind me.
Randy Konik
Yes. The overall inventory is down which is very good. I'm just trying to get some perspective on composition, a little color by division?
Sabrina Simmons
Sure. Okay. Got you. Yes, it's almost I would say by Channel, right. So we've been buying very tight in the specialty channel especially for Gap and Banana Republic given their tougher business. Old Navy obviously has also been very disciplined and bought very tightly. But that business is a business that moves units, right, there in the value sector so we move a lot of units especially this time of year. So they're probably have more inventory but from a historical perspective are also still bought very tightly. So specialty down the most and then Old Navy in our outlets to have a little bit more than the specialty channel I would say.
Randy Konik
Got it. Very helpful. Thank you.
Operator
The next question is Dana Telsey, Telsey Advisory Group.
Dana Telsey
Good afternoon, everyone. And Sabrina back of luck, congratulations, what a pleasure to work with you.
Sabrina Simmons
Thank you, Dana.
Dana Telsey
As you were talking about the advantage of scale, and if there's work still yet to be done, when does that pay-off? What does it look like, does it differ by brand, and does that differ by front-end and back-end, basically for both you and Sabrina? Thank you.
Arthur Peck
Yes, Dana, I would say that we’re -- I mean let me step back for a second, and I’ll just simplistically characterize the work that we're doing, which is we've operated this company historically more as independent businesses with relatively separate the duplicative activities inside of each business, not entirely because we had a common sourcing structure, a common IT platform etcetera, but in a lot of other places it's been relatively more independent. And the work that we're doing right now is to really build, turn the core operating platform by bringing all of those things together that are not customer-facing and then skinning that operating platform where it faces the customer and the brand needs to be expressed. And I've talked about that before, and that is a process is underway right now. And certainly doing that from a product standpoint, we moved first in terms of product a few years ago when we moved away from a geographic base sourcing that worked to a category based sourcing network, so there's one office doing denim for every brand on behalf of the company where we can then bring to bear our scale working with mills and vendors in order to get the best possible cost and the best possible quality simultaneously. It's been a bit mixed inside of other things as well. I think we have an opportunity especially in the environment we’re in right now, from the standpoint real estate now relationship with our landlords. And then there's just a wide variety of costs, some media that we buy and have bought separately, we are bringing together etcetera, so I’d love to tell you and give you an exact number, it is material and it will continue to progressively paid out. I mean, I’ve been very clear with the company on this one, that I want this done, I want it done ASAP, I want the benefits in hand and then we'll choose how much of those benefits we want to invest and how much those benefits we want to bring the bottom line.
Dana Telsey
Thank you.
Arthur Peck
Yep.
Operator
Our final question today will come from Oliver Chen, Cowen and Company.
Oliver Chen
Thank you. Sabrina thanks for the partnership and we’ll definitely miss you. I was just curious about how you're thinking about enter playing marketing programs versus where you feel that your product is right now, in terms of you know balancing that. And are, where where do you think that the Gap brand, and where do you think the assortment is, are you happy with the alignment with where you want the brand to be an optimism and said or which parts of the assortment, you know have opportunity? Thanks.
Arthur Peck
Yes, where I think the product is relative to our marketing is, as I think Old Navy is lined up appropriately and it shows in the business. I think we have -- I think the product is better than our business right now in Banana and Gap, not perfect by a long shot, but better than our business and therefore it's why we made the decision to put some marketing into the business is to start telling the story. You know I – when I was running Gap back in 2012, we fixed the product, we have a strong trend, and the business turned on a dime. Obviously I had hoped that that was going to happen here as the product better, it's not, it's tougher environment we are operating in right now with negative traffic, therefore the decision to put marketing into Q4 and to make sure that we are budgeting marketing as we go forward as well, really tell the story. And tell the story about all the product being on brand and on trend, but also about the restoration of quality of fit, of technical attributes, and those types of things as well. I have a very strong conviction, that successful brands today our story made brands, it's all around us, and you can see the ones that are telling the story and the ones that aren’t. And we have a great story to tell. We've just been a little too quiet with Banana and Gap. By design, well we’ve been quiet until we felt like the product merited telling the story. And that's really where my head is at right now. I think, I will take –I will take the credit here, we want it to be conservative on marketing because I did not want to invite aggressively invite customers back into our stores, and so I felt like the product was going to be where it needed to be. On Gap rent specifically, again it's not perfect, but the clarity of presentation that you should see in our stores where we've really tried to tighten up to a category merchandising. The trend that we have in our stores, and I asked the question the other day of all of our brands, so I just send a note out over the weekend as I was travelling and watching and listening to people, I said, just tell me we all had velvet [ph], and we all actually have velvet which is super on trend right now across every single one of our businesses from Athleta, Old Navy in the intermix. I feel like we're on a better spot, and we're getting better season over season as well. So I am not, as I said before, I’m cautiously optimistic on Q4, and I will continue to be as we look into next year. Thank you.
Oliver Chen
Thank you.
Arthur Peck
I’d like to thank everyone for joining us on the call today. As a reminder, the press release which is available on gapinc.com contains a full recap of our third quarter results, as well as the forward-looking guides included in today's prepared remarks. As always, the investor relations team will be available after the call for further questions. Thank you.
Operator
Ladies and gentlemen, that does conclude today's conference. You may now disconnect.